SubscribeGift a Sub
Enable cache 100
Horse Driving

The Right Stuff: How to Choose a Driving Horse

Virtually any breed of horse or pony can be used for driving. Shown: a senior Arabian mare, Sonny’s Negma, owned by Sue Connors. They won second place in the Pleasure Driving class at the Octoberfest Show at the Hoosier Horse Park in Indiana. Photo by Allen MacMillan

The sport of driving is a beautiful thing to watch, but it’s even more fun to participate. Two top professionals in the sport—Leslie Cashion of Louisville, Ky., and Jacob Arnold of Goshen, Ky.—offer some key points to consider on how to choose a driving horse.

Both strongly advise anyone new to driving to learn the sport from experienced drivers using schoolmaster horses before looking for their own driving horse. They suggest joining a local driving club to meet others already involved in the sport and to take advantage of the resources available through the American Driving Society (ADS), the Carriage Association of America (CAA) and the United States Equestrian Federation (USEF).

When you’re ready to begin your search for a horse with the mind and body for driving, it’s important to define the type of driving you’d like to do and your budget (with pre-purchase exam and equipment costs factored in).

Cashion, an active clinician who has taught and competed in driving for 22 years through the international levels and holds CAA Level 1 Instructor and Level 2 Driver proficiencies, cautions newbies not to fall in love with the first gorgeous creature they see, but to carefully think through your ability level and personal goals when selecting a horse.

“The animal that catches your eye may be stunning, but if he drives or rides like a fire-breathing dragon while you’re a green driver who needs a reliable Steady Eddie, this won’t be a good fit for you,” she warns.

Arnold has represented the U.S. at four FEI World Driving Championships in the last six years. He trains horses, teaches students and manages the driving program at Hermitage Farm in Kentucky. Also a busy USEF Developing Athlete Program clinician, he thinks most horses can adapt to driving. “Almost any horse can be trained to be correct,” he says. “You just have to find the right way to motivate them. If the horse is forward and likes to work and likes the game, he can overcome some conformational flaws.”

A Mind for the Job

Both experts topped their requirement list for a driving horse by talking about desirable mental traits.

Parades are another way to enjoy driving with your horse, but the activity requires the horse to be well trained and desensitized. Shown: An Arabian-Clydesdale cross pulling a Meadowbrook cart driven by owner Tracy Raikes of Lebanon, Ohio, in the town’s annual Christmas Carriage Pride. Photo by MacMillan Photography

A good mind: This was first on Cashion’s list for choosing a driving horse. She says a good mind for partnership and driving is of utmost importance.

“You want a horse that is not overly spooky, is trusting, and is able to learn new skills,” she says. “Even the most solid horse can spook, but a good brain is based on how they handle their fear. Will they listen to you and respond? Then you can work through scary moments. Do they want to react strongly without any known trigger or lack the ability to work through the scary moment? Then driving may not be for that horse.”

Forward-thinking: At the top of Arnold’s list was a horse that goes toward something he doesn’t know rather than backing away.

“I think all horses can be broken down into backward-thinking or forward-thinking horses,” he says. “Consider the horse that spooks and jumps back versus a horse that either doesn’t spook, or if he does spook, he goes forward. Those are the two basic mentalities of horses.”

Trainable: This trait ranked very high with both Cashion and Arnold. Cashion explains how she evaluates trainability.

“I like to try to teach the horse something new when I try him out,” she says. “I will choose something small, based on what I see in the moment, and tune in to how he responds. Does he want to figure out what I am asking of him, approaching with curiosity? Does he resist and become worried, shutting down or reacting strongly?”

Calm-minded: Arnold explains this as “a quiet, relaxed horse that doesn’t get fussed easily.”

Driving horses need to accept flapping tack, a vehicle following them, and wearing a bridle with blinders that only allows them to see what is directly in front of them, among other things.

He says that just how calm they need to be depends on the task. For combined driving, they may need to be more keen, whereas for pleasure driving and parades, they should probably be “about a 5 on a scale where 10 is super forward and 1 is not.”

Leslie Cashion driving a Haflinger gelding, Winterson’s Gold, in the marathon phase at a combined driving event in Ohio. Photo by Pics of You/John Robinson,

Smart: Arnold prefers his driving horses to be clever. “They can pick up on the game quickly,” he says. “For example, some horses I have driven really love the cones phase of combined driving—they love the game of going in between the cones; they know when we cross the start and when we get to cone 20 and look for the finish.”

Willing to stand: Driving horses need to stand longer than riding horses in order to be hitched or if something needs to be repaired while away from the barn.

“Trying to convince your horse to stand still while adjusting a piece of equipment, if it isn’t already in his toolkit, is a recipe for trouble,” says Cashion.

Good steering: When choosing a driving horse, Arnold emphasizes that it is important that a driving horse steers well and understands steering on two direct reins.

A Body Up to the Task

The other half of the list provided by Cashion and Arnold involved physical attributes: conformation and movement. Here is a quick summary of what they recommend.

A wide chest for more effective positioning of the breastplate to pull the carriage and to allow for easy breathing.

A neck that comes high out of the shoulder and is not too short; this also helps with room for breathing and effective pulling.

A solid, short-coupled build allows for a good back-to-front connection for pulling power.

Strong, ample hindquarters are the engine for pushing.

Good feet and legs for longevity of soundness. Quality of movement is important for competition, but also affects soundness; a naturally good walk and a solid working trot are very important.

Pleasure driving can be “just for fun,” for exhibition, or for competition, with many open and breed-specific shows offering pleasure driving classes. Shown: a Welsh Cob in the Welsh pleasure driving class during the Royal Agricultural Winter Fair in Toronto, Canada. Photo by Sarah Miller/MacMillan Photography

The Wrong Stuff

Cashion says horses that would not be good driving candidates include those that often bolt out of control, are prone to bucking or kicking, or are not willing to work. She also cautions against horses that cannot overcome being very noise-sensitive and those that are not serviceably sound.

“If you don’t feel confident riding or handling your horse, you won’t feel safe sitting behind him in a carriage,” she warns.

Parting Advice

Both professionals encourage others to try driving. “Driving is the most fun you can have while partnering with your horse,” says Cashion. “Buy or train the horse that best fits you. Make sure the people you trust to give advice are acting in your best interest, not their own pocketbooks. The sport of driving has some of the best people and equines in the world, if you know where to look!”

Driving Resources

American Driving Society
The Carriage Association of America
United States Equestrian Federation
The National Drive

This article on how to choose a driving horse appeared in the May 2021 issue of
Horse Illustrated magazine. Click here to subscribe!

Kim MacMillan

Kim MacMillan graduated from Purdue University where she majored in agriculture communications and animal science. She has been reporting on equestrian sports, agriculture, science, travel and history for over 35 years. She and her husband Allen, who is a professional photographer, have covered several World Equestrian, Olympic and Pan American Games. The MacMillans share their Northeastern Indiana farm with several much-loved horses, dogs and cats.

Recent Posts

Tips to Keep Your Horse from Bucking

It’s a scene riders dread: A tense, strong horse ignores your cues, moves straight ahead then begins bucking and kicking…

7 hours ago

ASPCA Right Horse Summit: Rescue Intake Exams

The 2023 ASPCA Right Horse Summit, in Lexington Kentucky, kicked off with a discussion about intake and assessment best practices.…

4 days ago

Vet Adventures: Prolonging a Procedure

I wasn’t worried about performing the actual mass removal; it was a procedure I’d done on many horses and wasn’t…

4 days ago

ASPCA Right Horse Adoptable Horse of the Week: Draco

Welcome to Horse Illustrated’s weekly installment of the Right Horse Adoptable Horse of the Week, offered in partnership with the…

5 days ago

All About the Palomino Horse

There is something about a Palomino horse that gets people’s attention. That could be why Xena the Warrior Princess, cowboy…

1 week ago

Groundwork Exercises to Improve Communication

Groundwork exercises that check communication between horse and human are a crucial part of my evaluation of a new horse…

1 week ago